A response to lois pineaus article about date rape

Ezra Klein supports California's "yes means yes" law for the state's colleges on the grounds that there are too many sexual assaults; as such, he endorses broad new legal measures like California's newly created law. Honest and open discussion about sexual intent would promote mutual interest and benefit.

The theft would still be a crime, but would I have any complicity in that crime. Because children born of slave mothers were slaves, regardless of their paternity, many slave owners benefited from rape by producing more slaves for themselves.

The violation of bodily and sexual autonomy is no doubt among rape's most central harms. Seifert criticizes the common view of rape as simply a regrettable byproduct of wartime social breakdown and lack of military discipline as well as of naturally aggressive male sexualitycontending that, in fact, rape is a routine element of military strategy, aimed at undermining the will, morale, cohesion, and self-conception of the enemy population.

When such acts are committed with genocidal intent, the victim is not only the individual targeted, but the group itself. Because a person's body is at the very center of her domain and is the locus of the properties and capacities that make her a person, the intentional invasion of the body is an especially egregious attack: An interesting difference of opinion arises when trying to compare and contrast the writings of Lois Pineau and Camille Paglia on the issue of consent.

At most, a court could order the person who broke the contract to provide non-sexual compensation. It bears noting that successful rape prosecutions depend not only on how rape is legally defined but, at least equally importantly, on the general public's willingness to believe women's testimony rather than seeing them as lying or confused and to recognize particular encounters as instances of the applicable legal definition that is, to see this behavior as force, or this utterance as expressing nonconsent.

The message was that white women desperately needed white men's protection, not only in the usual form of restrictions on the women's behavior and mobility, but also by the men's efforts to control and kill off dangerous natives.

She argues that the process is biased because it makes assumptions about the nature of sex, and the differences between male and female sexuality, which are totally wrong. The continuing prevalence of such rape-supportive beliefs can render even well-intentioned prosecutors unwilling to pursue legitimate cases, given the likelihood that juries will refuse to convict.

First, in stark contrast to other legal areas e. Communicative sexuality is most likely to be rewarding for both parties, allows them to promote each other's sensual ends non-manipulatively and non-paternalistically, and observes norms appropriate to friendship and trust.

Feminists have highlighted the ways in which the institution of rape reinforces the group-based subordination of women to men: It is an agreement where comprehensive consent is given in advance, with the intent of it being irrevocable under most circumstances.

In determining who, if anyone, was really at fault in these acts, it became necessary to consider attitudes about sexuality and consent. It is irresponsible to knowingly act in ways that put us in danger. Another myth — there is an expectation that women are coy about their sexual desires.

For anyone who wishes to better understand why date rape IS rape, this book is a necessary read. In order to colonize a people whose society was not hierarchical, colonizers must first naturalize hierarchy through instituting patriarchy.

Consent, or rather what qualifies as an incidence of consent, further complicates the issue.

Sexual consent

Frye and Shafer emphasize that rape's communication of this message constitutes one significant element of its harm: These and other power relationships in turn make women and girls even more vulnerable to rape. In light both of these numbers and of rape's broader ideological dynamics and social consequences, feminists have long contended that rape harms not only its individual victims, but also women as a class.

Goodhart argues that the rapist-fathers have violated the rights not only of the women they rape, but also of the children thereby produced. The idea here is not to prohibit sexual contact between hierarchical unequals per se but to legally interpret sex that a hierarchical subordinate says was unwanted in the context of the forms of force that animate the hierarchy between the parties.

According to the No Model, a sexual act is consensual unless the victim says no or resists physically. Sexual consent is consent to engage in sexual activity. Sexual activity without consent is considered rape or other sexual assault.

In the late s, academic Lois Pineau argued that society must move towards a more communicative model of sexuality so that consent becomes more explicit and clear, objective and layered, with a more comprehensive model than "no means no" or "yes means yes".

A response to lois pineaus article about date rape

Date Rape (Lois Pineau) - Date rape is non-aggravated sexual assault, non-consensual sex that does not involve physical injury, or the explicit threat of physical injury () - Pineau argues that the current standard of adjudicating charges of date rape are turnonepoundintoonemillion.comd: Apr 27, LOIS PINEAU c Date Rape: A Feminist Analysis Lois Pineau is a professor of philosophy at Kansas State University.

Pineau defines date rape as nonconsensual sex that does not involve physical injury.

Feminist Perspectives on Rape

The requirement by courts of evidence of physical injury, she argues, stems from myths that women are sex- ually provocative and asking for it, and that men’s sexual desires are uncontrollable. Pineau says that now (the article was written in ) there is very little legal protection from sexual assault for a woman on a casual date with a stranger.

This is partly because it is very hard to corroborate the woman's claims that she did not give consent. Date Rape.

Radically Queer

Feminism, Philosophy, and the Law. Edited by Leslie Francis “Date Rape is a remarkable contribution to the field of feminist thought. For anyone who wishes to better understand why date rape IS rape, this book is a necessary read.

Lois Pineau defines date rape as, “Nonaggravated sexual assault, nonconsensual sex that does not involve physical injury, or the explicit threat of physical injury” [1] While the motivation behind rape and date rape may differ diametrically, the effects on the victims of both can be traumatic and long lasting.

A response to lois pineaus article about date rape
Rated 5/5 based on 28 review
Lois Pineau, Date Rape - PhilPapers